Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Dick Hackborn

 Wow, while I wasn't looking, we lost another of our stalwarts from the old HP

Dick Hackborn, whose best work was architecting and building the HP Peripherals musiness into the giant that is still HP Inc., passed away in August 2025.   

He thus joined a large community of executive level colleagues who passed at nearly the same time.

John Young, Bill Terry, Carl Cottrell, Dean Morton, Doug Chance's wife, and many others.  We're all of 'an age'

Many people missed understanding Hackborn. Bear in mind this man was responsible for much of HP's success in the 'middle years' and then went to be Chairman of Microsoft, and -- oh by the way -- hired Carly Fiorina (which did not endeare him to the HP faithful).

Somehow, I got to know Dick pretty well, and he gave me plenty of coaching and guidance in the Corporate Engineering job.   He was one of a kind in my view.

One story is easy to recall.  I was asked by Rosabeth Cantor, head of the Harvard Business Review, to chair a celebratory dinner in San Francisco in spring 1991.  Maybe 250 people in a fancy room atop the Transamerica building as I recall, and Rosabeth wanted me to emcee for two articles in the Jan issue--the Feature article, "Marketing is Everything" was by the well-known Regis McKenna.  He came to the podioum, boasting about how he had crafted Apple's successful strategies.  Then John Seeley Brown, head of XeroxPARC at the time, extolled his article "Research that re-invents the corporation."  The issue had "The Return Map" from Ray Price and me in it as well, which is why Rosabeth included me.

After their speeches, I was emcee'ing and several good questions arose.  And then someone baited me, on what I cannot recall.  But I had one of those moments--where you look down on yourself from above, and the lips are moving and you are just in an out-of-body experience.  I heard myself say, that our article--The Return Map --described the techniques that Dick Hackborn used to build the HP printer divisions, which had swamped out all the work that Brown described (HP buried Xerox in small office prointers from 1984-1990, remember?), and that Dick's work there and with the HP PC side had outsold Apple by two times, while they used McKenna's early MacIntosh strategy.  It's now well known that the Mac, innovative as it was, was a dismal failure sales-wise for several years.  Jobs had been fired, Sculley ultimately built the company to $8B before declining margins caught him.

The room exploded, with shouts all over the room.  And my thesis got most of the enthusiasm, if I do say so myself.   But the ride down in the elevator with JSB, who is actually a good friend, was quiet.

But that was how Dick usually worked.  Quietly, behind the scenes, not much fuss.  We miss him.

Here's his obituary, from the Idaho chapel where his services were held.

Richard “Dick” Allen Hackborn was born in Detroit, Michigan on May 25, 1937, and passed away peacefully in Boise, Idaho, on August 16, 2025 at the age of 88. He was preceded in death by his parents Gordon Edward Hackborn and Marie (Vinson) Hackborn, and by his beloved wife Sondra Ilene (Shaw) Hackborn. He is survived by his sister, Joan Hoover; his children, Dianne K. Hackborn and Eric S. Hackborn; his daughter-in-law, Kerri Lynne Thorp; and his cherished granddaughter, Halo Marie Hackborn. Dick was a devoted husband, a dedicated father, a proud grandfather, a community philanthropist, an innovator, and an ethical business leader who deeply cared about the success and well-being of the people around him.


Dick’s early education was at the Breck School in Minnesota, but the family relocated to Edina in 1950 for the excellent public schools. Since he was young he has always taken care of the people around him, and his generous spirit led him to tutor his sister when he realized she needed extra help with her math studies. He chose not to apply the same standards to himself and was a poor student in his initial years at Edina High School, instead spending his time roaming in his 1933 Ford coupe, playing football, and probably chasing girls while wearing his “You’ll Love Clem’s Buns” t-shirt. His football coach / math teacher turned him around at the end of his junior year and his grades improved enough to squeak into admittance at the University of Minnesota on probation in 1955. During his time in college he maintained a high GPA while also working summers at Control Data Corporation, designing memory sense-amplifier circuits for Seymour Cray. He graduated in 1960 with a Bachelor’s of Science in Electrical Engineering, and that same year also had the honor of being a groomsman in his sister’s wedding to his good friend Paul. His adventure was just beginning, but his curiosity, determination, and healthy sense of mischief would carry him far.


After accidentally interviewing with Hewlett Packard during a career fair he accepted a position as a design engineer working for Paul Stoft, and moved across the country to Palo Alto, CA, where there was less snow and more sun. He spent several years working on instrumentation at HP while simultaneously getting an MBA from Santa Clara in 1963 and then completing the coursework for a PhD from Stanford (though he never wrote a thesis, opting instead to work).


Dick met Sondra Ilene Shaw in late 1965 at a pre-season ski party, a chance encounter that would shape the rest of his life. Shortly after they met he was nominated by Dave Packard to participate in the inaugural Rotary International Exchange and spent three formative months in Japan. Even from across the world, Sondra remained at the center of his thoughts. He returned in June and they married on August 13, 1966, the very same year Star Trek debuted. Dick described Sondra as the center of his being and his lifelong soulmate, his partner in every adventure, and the person whose love, warmth, and creativity gave his life its deepest meaning.


Dick enjoyed a continuous stream of new opportunities and challenges during his time at HP. In 1967 he moved from engineering to management when he was given responsibility for integrating early minicomputers with HP instrumentation. In 1971 he transferred to the computer division as engineering manager for all hardware and software development, where his team introduced the first HP business computer systems, which became very successful. In 1977 he was named manager of the Disk Storage Division and located it in Boise, Idaho, where Ray Smelek had already established the successful tape drive division. The move to Boise would prove to be a meaningful change not just for his family and the families that joined them, but also for the Treasure Valley, as HP’s future growth would contribute significantly to the area’s expanding tech industry.


In 1979 he became general manager of peripherals, and in the early 1980s his division became the world leader of LaserJet and InkJet printers, quickly generating a major portion of HP’s revenues and profits. InkJet printers were developed entirely within HP, while the main technology for LaserJets was licensed from Canon, an uncommon strategy for HP at that time.


His role changed again in 1983, giving up peripherals to focus on integrating the globally-disparate networking teams. In 1984 he was named general manager of the reconstituted Peripherals Group, combining his new networking and previous printer and storage divisions. In 1990 he was given responsibility for PCs, and he finally retired in December of 1993 as Executive Vice President of the Computer Products organization.


Dick has been recognized as one of HP’s most visionary and successful leaders. Early mentorship from Dave Packard taught him many important lessons, such as identifying client needs, not attacking a fortified hill, and understanding your contribution. His fascination with history was likely instrumental to his uncanny ability to predict trends. He led teams with an empathy and kindness that made him a natural consensus builder. Colleagues admired not only his vision, but his calm demeanor, careful listening, and instinct to lift others up rather than seek credit for himself.


After retiring, Dick spent years keeping busy on various boards: He was a member of the HP board from 1992 to 2009, the Microsoft board from 1994 to 2000, a director of the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation from 1996 to 2001, and started his own family philanthropic organization, the Hackborn Foundation, in 1997. His philanthropic work reflected values he shared with Sondra: education, creativity, fairness, and expanding opportunity for others.


Richard and Sondra donated generously to the arts, gifting regularly to local Boise dance and theater groups and supporting individual artists. They were members of the Boise Art Museum Collectors Forum, traveling with close friends to explore museums and collections throughout the world.


Dick avoided the spotlight, preferring to see others receive recognition and credit, but has still received honors and awards: He was analyzed as “Jack Wakefield” in the book The Gamesman in 1976; he was an Outstanding Achievement Award recipient from the University of Minnesota Institute of Technology in 2005; he was an Idaho Technology Council Hall of Fame recipient in 2010.


Dick was not social by choice, but always fun at gatherings. He accompanied Sondra to various events and parties around town, and they also hosted many large events at their home including, perhaps involuntarily, a Star Trek-themed 50th wedding anniversary.


As a father, Dick was deeply proud of the successful, loving, and ethical people his children grew into. The births of Dianne in 1971 and Eric in 1973 were among the greatest joys of his life, milestones that anchored him deeply in family and gave him a profound sense of purpose. Though his work often took him around the world, Dick always kept his children close at heart, returning home with small technological wonders and thoughtfully saving the handwritten notes they gave him. He took pride in them not only for what they accomplished, but for who they became. Even as adults, Dick continued to watch over them, faithfully tracking their flights and travels as he had since they first left home. Dick led by example, teaching curiosity, independence, ethics, and resilience. He placed their happiness and success at the core of his life, encouraging them to find their own paths while offering steady guidance and support. In 2020, Dick became a grandfather to his only grandchild, Halo. He delighted in Halo’s bright smile, boundless curiosity, and budding engineering spirit, but most of all, he found joy in watching Eric become a father and in the loving bond Eric built with his daughter.


By August 16, Dick had been a successful businessman, a wonderful son, brother, partner, father, grandfather, and a respected friend. He had adventured the world: Gone on safari in Africa, observed bears in the wilds of Alaska, cruised the Danube, charted the Iberian Peninsula, wandered the Alhambra, and explored many more places. August 16 was a sunny afternoon, threadbare clouds stitched over the Boise foothills. It was a peaceful day to slip away, off to his next grand adventure.


Community was at the heart of Dick’s world. He could lose himself in deep technical and historical topics, but his true joy was supporting the growth of the people around him. When he spoke about work he made frequent mention of the many admired coworkers he’d known along the way. When he spoke to family he always checked in to make sure everyone was healthy and happy. His home contained notes he’d written to himself with thoughts to help people he loved through difficult times. To all the people who knew him, all the stories we know and the stories we don’t, we are forever grateful you were a part of his beautiful journey.



Thursday, November 12, 2026

HPE and others on quite the Silicon Valley ride

 Well, I got a bit out of practice regarding the stock market.  But my nephew's wife, a 27-year veteran of HPE, came for dinner several weeks ago, and said, "Have you seen HPE stock lately?"

"No," I replied, "Why?"   

She smiled and said, "It nearly hit 75 this week, after YEARS wandering in the 25's range."

So, I went back and looked at a bew things.  OHMYGAWD.   Was I the jinx?

Feb 28, 2026, my wife's birthday, HPE was at $21.47.   October 9, 2026, 'the dinner cited above, HPE was at $73.46.   Should have kept more of that stock!

So, armed with that excitement, I spent the next month watching . . . watching the market go to hell

The opening salvo was Alphabet posting a very positive earnings statement after the market on October 28, with revenues up 25% and earnings up 30% year-over-year.  Stock closed at $3231.89.   The next day, it closed at $282.32.  HUH?   A DROP of 12.8% after a report like that?

Analysts, who usually are so knowledgeable, attributed a bad review about upcoming data centers.

Here's tha table for a few other stocks I decided to 'watch' for a few days


A few days?   Like TEN DAYS, or like ONE MONTH?

Now, granted, we had a national election on Novembere 3, 2026, with a nearly unprecedented  Blue Tsunami, but I don't think that is the big story here.  Stock like Amazon, Costco, Meercedes, Tesla, and Microsoft held up just fine.   But look at these five.

And then, here we are on Thursday November 12, and Nvidia (closing yesterday at $173.40) had a little contretemps with its founder and long-term CEO, Jen-sen Huang deciding to retire late last night in a conversaetio with his board.  Nvidia closed today at $166.19 after opening at a stunning $151.09.

The GOOD NEWS (you have to seaarch a bit here) is that in the past seven days:

HPE is back to $50.16 (up 12.0%)

Intel is at $61.20 (up 8.7%)

Dell is at $371.17. (up 13.0%)

and Lumentum crawled back to $624.65. (up 16.0%)

For this one week, Nvidia is down only 10.3% at the close.

I know, I know, watching these markets could drive one batty . . . .

Maybe that explains things.

BUT, BREAKING NEWS -- you won't find this bit of gossip on MSNOW or in the Merc tomorrow

We have a very close friend in Santa Rosa who had news about 15 mintues ago

She is a long-time Santa Rosa gal, lived next door to Charlie Schultz for years.  Both homes were destroyed in the Santa Rosa fire.  She rebuilt.  And ironic, along the way, she and HP VP Hal Edmondson became close.  They were driving in separate cars, her behind him, when he was killed in an auto accident in 2012.   She and my wife Jenny are close Berkeley classmates, seeing each other monthly.

Her son just was retained by Jen-sen Huang.

Howze that for small Valley doings

All the best

Chuck

Sunday, November 1, 2026

Egon Loebner and the Soviets

 Strange and wonderful notes get sent my way from time to time.   Here is one from Chuck Morehouse, a stalwart HP Labs researcher from the 1970-1990 era.   

    • Chuck,
    • I have a question about long-ago HP that you might know something about.  It is about Egon Loebner.  I have just watched a PBS Compass Points report on a new book on the Havana Syndrome.  I have heard many reports on this but never one that mentions a story about Egon that was circulating anound HP Labs around the time I first joined in the early 1980s.
    •  
    • The story was that Egon went to Moscow to investigate rumors of a mysterious illness of some members of the US Embassy.  The suspicion was that it might be caused by some sort of radio or microwave radiation bathing the Embassy.  The story was that he was able to confirm with direct measurements that the Russians were bathing the Embassy with microwaves.
    •  
    • Do you have any knowledge of this story?  Might it be true but the story was covered up officially but could still linger in HP Labs among Egon's colleagues?
    •  
    • Any thoughts you have on this would be appreciated.
    •  
    • Cheers,
    • Chuck Morehouse
So, a little background.  Loebner was a survivor of Auschwitz thanks to his scientific and engineering capabolity which the Germans exploited.  His parents, imprisoned with him, did not survive.   this colored his outlook for a lifetime, as did his deep scientific questing mind.   After deep work on opto-electronics at RCA, he joined HP, and as fate had it, encountered both Hewlett and Packard who each had experience working to promote deeper Soviet - US scientnfic relations.   I won't expound on them further here, but it should be done in a subsequent post.  The upshot was that Egon was sponsored to become an emissary to Moscow, a task he did with some reservations.


The story that Morehouse asks about occurred later, as the following account reveals:


My answer to Morehouse was:

Chuck, I have heard that story several times, but all of them a long time ago.   I didn’t know him very well; Doyle and Hammond did, but they’re both gone.  Binnbaum may know about this???

 

There are lots of ’stories’ but hard to pin them down unless it was someone who really knew.   And if you knew, it was hard to mention sometimes.    Example—the Santa Rosa site was unclear-hardened per Packard’s explicit instructions, but Doug Chance (who ran it, and oversaw construction even for a period) didn’t know that until I told him thirty years later.  I snuck that tidbit into The HP Phenomenon (page 489) in an innocuous paragraph 

 

You might also try John Minck, who has a penchant for wonderful details from HP.  I am including him here.

 

There is apparently an autobiography of Egon’s.   This outlines the first seven chapters https://shoah.deportal.cz/shoah/document/10 

 

That’d be fascinating to find and read.   I think his son may still be living. Gary Loenere, but I couldn’t find him in LinedIn

 

Egon’s Ancestry.com data is at https://www.ancestry.com/family-tree/person/tree/161347171/person/112125226517/facts    It notes three offspring, but no names, which says they were still living when the form was filled out

 

Sorry that I cannot be more helpful

 

Chuck

Well, the note bore fruit.  HP super-hisstorian John Minck rose to the challenge magnificently:

Hi Chuck (Morehouse, not me),

I got to know Egon fairly well, he was an LED expert with experience at RCA before HP. I wrote him up in my Narrative History of HP 

and will attach a copy. The incident of the Embassy microwaves is true, because Egon told me about it. I've forgotten which administration was in DC but it was when Packard was appointed as Deputy Secretary of Defense. Egon was recruited to be a Technical Attache in the American Embassy, for three years. The staff there was getting serious medical issues, some more than others, but they finally did some measurements and found that the Embassy was being bombarded by high power microwaves. It turns out that speech audio vibrations of the windows would reflect enough power to detect audio. 

The technical folks then built a separate room inside another room, with those acoustic pyramids, and secret meetings were held there. Plus they covered all internal rooms with aluminum foil to shield the place. 

Egon also told me that the Russians had built a brand new building to be used for the American Embassy, and filled it with hidden microphones, in light fixtures, etc. My memory fades now, but some idea persisits that the Embassy might have taken other buildings where they weren't bugged ahead of time. 

Now that I think about it, the foil would have given strong reflections for the audio recovery? 

If you have other specific questions, just ask.

John 

Anyone doubt the value of 'old-timers' still on the scene?

Anyway thanks to Chuck Morehouse for raising the question and for John to answer it.

All the bst

Chuck House 

Friday, June 5, 2026

Do yu remember "Halo"?

 Funny some things cycle and recycle, you just never know when to expect them.   A recent post by Phil McKinney, one of HP's genuine innovators along the way, recalled some 'forgotten video conferencing lore' that is perhaps worth revisiting (or maybe, for most of you, visiting for the first time).

Here's Phil's LinkedIn post: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/question-nobody-wanted-ask-phil-mckinney-jtd1c/

Finding Ideas 
Most innovation fails quietly. The warnings were there. Forty years of what nobody wanted to say

Something I keep seeing in boardrooms, innovation teams, and strategy sessions, including my own, is that the most expensive mistakes rarely come from bad ideas. They come from good ideas built on assumptions nobody thought to question.

Not because the people in the room were careless. Because the assumption felt so obvious it stopped feeling like an assumption. It just felt like the plan.

That's what I keep coming back to this week.

─────────────────────────────

✦ This Week — Studio Sessions

Inversion Thinking: How to Guarantee Your Project Fails (On Purpose)

In 2005, I was at HP when we built Halo. Best telepresence system in the world. Life-sized. Perfect audio. Nobody had built anything close.

The team was brilliant. The technology was extraordinary. And we were completely wrong about the one thing that mattered.

We believed quality wins. It felt so obvious that nobody in the room thought to question it. Not once. Not out loud.

It wasn't quality the market was buying. It was access. Cisco understood that. Then Zoom made it a verb. We invented the category and handed it to them.

In 2011, under quarterly pressure, HP sold Halo to Polycom for $89 million. In 2022, HP bought the business back for $3.3 billion. Thirty-seven times the price. To reacquire a category we'd invented.

The failure wasn't hidden. It was sitting inside one assumption the entire time. An inversion exercise, asking "how would we guarantee this fails," would have dragged it into the open in the first planning meeting. The answer was already in the plan. We just never read it from the other side.

Phil is right when he wrote that Halo was 'the best telepresence system in the world."  My Collab team at Intel did 'bake-offs' for three years (2003-2006) of all the extant systems.  HP was far and away the technology and user preference leader, for several reasons that I'll cover below.

This should not have been surprising.  HP was among the first to invest heavily in Computer-aided Teleconferencing.   That story has only lightly been told in other venues, and I'll just briefly recount it here.  But the sequence is fascinating, not just for HP's prescience and then failure, not just once but twice, but also for other companies (notably Intel and Cisco) trying and failing almost precisely for the same reasons.   So there must be something endemic about what Phil has described in terms of overlooking the obvious. 

Phil was wrong, though when he says "Cisco understood that it was Access."   NOPE, they blew this one bigger than HP, especially because they thought "Access" meant for a select few, not everyone.  So they chased a small company that did think "access" and Cisco proceeded to completely miss the target.

First of all, although Phil doesn't mention that the 'chief competitor' to Halo at introduction was Cisco's Telepresence, they were the two "big kahunas".   Here are pictures of each, Halo first.  Note that Halo includes a big screen at the top, whereas Cisco's room does not.   That is one part of the story.

The HP "Halo" 'room'

The Cisco "Telepresence" room

Both systems were backed, actually stimulated even and then strongly promoted, by the respective CEOs, Carly Fiorina and John Chambers.  Each system cost roughly $350,000 per 'room' with a hefty ongoing networking and maintenance bill as well.   And each system had to connect to a similar systm elesewhere in order to establish a "meeting".  This meant that there was a premium on getting many systems installed so that meetings could happen between folks you wanted to have meet.  Also turned out hard to call a Cisco room from an HP room, or vice versa.

At that price, not everyone could afford such a proposition, and if you did (Cisco ultimately had 100's of 'in-house' systems for their own employees, and for their extended sales offices; HP's 'in-house' sites never totalled more than 100).   Cisco once boasted nearly 1,000 corporations having a system; HP never posted installation numbers, but  projections beyond 100 other corporations were scarce.  

There were two significant differences between HP's technological solution and Cisco's.   First, HP had the additional screen, so that "data" could be shared as well as people's smiling faces.  Some Cisco installations had small (21") screens at the far right and far left of the room to try to show the same thing (ZERO visibility for anyone interested in numbers).  Turns out Chamber is dyslexic, and he insisted that he wanted to see and feel the 'human' in the communication--data was largely extraneous (which by the way is how he mostly managed).   

The more fundamental issue was that Cisco's system was optimized with cameras that all focused on the center seat.   This had the unfortunate side effect that someone sitting to the left of the center seat could not address the person sitting directly across from them, nor could they address people seated at the far diagonal screen, without each Virtual group turning their gaze away from, rather than toward, the person addressing them from the side screen.  It was the ultimate "command-and-control catbird seat" to be in the center.   HP's system, correctly positioned with more strategically thought-out cameras, allowed anyone in a seemingly face-to-face screen set-up to talk to that person.  

The spec sheets didn't reveal any of that, but users quickly noticed this aberration.  Here are classical specs--unbelievably great and analogous technology for each system, except for these two deviations:

Cisco® TelePresence is an innovative new technology that combines rich audio, high-definition video, and interactive elements to deliver a unique, “in-person” experience—over the network. It is designed to bring users closer to the important people, places, and events in their personal and professional lives. The first application, the Cisco TelePresence Meeting solution, creates a live, face-to-face meeting experience, empowering users to interact and collaborate like never before. The Cisco TelePresence Meeting is purpose-built to be a completely different meeting experience, taking interaction and collaboration to a new level. Because it feels like everyone is in the same room, remote interactions are just as natural and effective as in-person communication, simplifying and accelerating information sharing throughout your organization—thereby impacting your top and bottom lines.

Key Benefits

Cisco TelePresence lets you improve productivity and responsiveness by focusing on more interactions with the right resource at the right time. It speeds time to market and enables faster decision making. At the same time, you can improve quality of life by giving employees back valuable time and, more importantly, control over their time with solutions that are as high-performance as they are. Imagine bringing more resources into an account for sales or support, and extending your reach and relationships without ever leaving your office.
Critical to delivering this experience are breakthrough innovations in delivering very high-quality audio and ultra high-definition video at very low latency with limited bandwidth utilization, in addition to the meeting environment itself. The Cisco TelePresence Meeting solution delivers true life-size images, ultra-high-definition video (both 720p and 1080p), and spatial audio, which creates the dynamics of voices coming directly from the participants. This scenario creates a “room within a room” environment that makes users feel as if they are at the same table with people in remote locations. In addition to direct eye contact, the full-duplex, near-zero latency allows users to communicate in real time, catching every comment and every nuance of the conversation. Every expression, every gesture is now clearly visible, whether you are meeting across town or across time zones.

Another user experience was notable for both HP and Cisco 'room administrators' (which were a necessary side operational cost).  THE WRONG PEOPLE are using the systems.   Both Carly and John believed that these were intentionally built for their key executives, to minimize travel costs and times, and to maximize their exposure time to key account executives.  Instead, between 80% and 90% of the users were 'low-status' folk, from the quality department, or personnel, or manufacturing logistics folk, or even folk who had no official standing but just wanted to talk to a friend or colleague elsewhere.  The common characteric of these users was that they usually could not get approval for company travel wherease the top execs had no trouble getting travel budgets approved.  Moreover, the top execs, despite their avowed stated beliefs, LOVED the travel perq, and were loathe to give it up.   Excuses like "It's just not the same if you're not there to press the flesh" abounded.  HP learned this in 1985; and had to relearn it in 2004, because everyone who learned it the first time had retired, left, or died.

The ultimate ACCESS test was, akin to Phil's observations, when Ciscc bought WebEx, in order to capture a larger user community.   WebEx at the time was a subscription service, with a clunky interface that Cisco managed to mangle even worse.   Eric Yuan was VP R&D for WebEx, and he kept explaining, almost ad nauseam, to Cisco officials what was needed.  Totally ignored, he left and started Zoom, with major funding from Cisco's SVP and legal counsel, Dan Scheinman who coincidentally quit Cisco the same day.  Scheinman's cousin provided VC funding later, and became a long-standing Zoom Board member.  Zoom's first customer was Stanford, where MediaX and Terry Winograd in CS had both been advocates.  

Note: I participated in three 'firsts' here actually.  A. Running MediaX where we did a fair amount of Zoom pre-practice in 2011.  B.  I was actually Webex's first user-customer for Dialogic in 1997--when they still sold the software as a product.  In fact, I wrote three papers about Video conferencing systems and a major C-Suite study (see below).   C.  I helped define HP's first efforts, and thereby authored Cisco's first commercial sale, using their early router to develop our HP Internet in 1985.  The story here (which I did NOT know for another 25 years) was that not only was my signature their first sale, but HP was their ONLY commercial customer for 27 months (when Boeing, thanks we think to Dave Packard telling Ted Wilson and Frank Shrontz how well it worked) became Cisco's 2nd commercial cusstomer.

Here are several studies that I published later via Intel and InnovaScapes Institute

(1) (PDF) Distributed Teams—Challenges and Opportunities. Available from: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/335640480_Distributed_Teams-Challenges_and_Opportuniti.  Published in Resarch Technology Management, 2019

(2) https://www.researchgate.net/publication/287205434_Confronting_Culture_Clash   Published in Research Technology Management, 2015.  The specific HP Internet development in 1984-1985, and the cisco systems role (early, the name was not capitalized) are well covered here.   This paper describes the same "Wrong people using the system" phenomenon already discovered by 1987.

(3) https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/5230814   "It depends on your point of View"  January 2009, IEEE Signal Processing Magazine, and IEEE Xplore.

(4) https://doi.org/10.1109/HICSS.2005.3    January 2005, HICSS 38, "Information worker Tools selection, adoption, and evaluation, Chuck House.  This paper explicitly mentions WebEx by name, and shows extensive graphs re value of various capabilities.

A couple of other historical points could be made.  Intel, with Pat Gelsinger as the lead designer and Exec, along with Andy Grove, bet heavily on Workstation-based Video teleconferencing with Team Station.  See the clear article by John James W. published June 11, 2024
https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/intel-teamstation-visionary-leap-collaboration-john-james-worrall-1rane/ 

I bought several of these for Dialogic in 1998/1999, and they were incredibly painful to use compared to the G-job terminals we had buiit for our HP system in 1985.   Not the least issue was the "look 'em in the eyeball, not the eye" problem of the off-axis camera.   But they did work, and though pricey, at $12,000 per terminal, they were lots cheaper than a $350,000 'room'.  This was a partnership with PictureTel, who while the leader, had some primitive tools at the time (and a number of the old HP guys).  The goal was to extend this into cheaper PCs, and ubiquitous 'telephone directories'.  Alas, the networks weren't yet up to it, and in particular, the advantages of IPv6 network protocols weren't yet available.   Nor were multi-core chipsets, so that any slow node could be isolated from others rather than dragging all concurrent users to a depressingly low level.

One more sidenote--we now know that the off-axis camera and lack of 'seeing you eye to eye' has largely ceased to be a problem.   It built mistrust in early systems, but today most people really don't look you in the eye--its body language, or room topology, or voice tonality that win the day

Okay, okay, so much for rambling through a long and tortured history.  But think where we'd have been in the COVID days if Zoom hadn't existed.



Wednesday, June 3, 2026

More interesting than obituaries

 Several have commented that I seem too focused on HPites dying, rather than what is happening at our old company.   So, just to give you an idea, we're always open to communication with living, breathing, functioning, achieving HPites.  This week, for example, I have heard from a wide swath of folk due to a modest update to my own LinkedIn page.

Dave Dayton, who became General Manager of the Logic Systems Division in C Springs when I moved to Palo Alto, sent a note, among other things mentioning that his watercolor hobby has progressed nicely.  He said, Check it out: ddaytonartist.blogpost.com 

Greg Peters, sent notes about the HUGE run-ip n KEYS stock price recently.  I shoulda, coulda, didn't have enough.   He sends notes periodically, includes Jay Alexander usually, sometime4s adds Mike Davis and others from C Springs.  Greg lives in the Napa Valley, still consulting in the quantum computing space.  Here's the front end of his note" KEYS is doing very well at the moment in large part due to the massive AI investments going on around the world. Data centers use lots of cables and connectors and KEYS is extremely well positioned to address those design and measurement needs – including everybody’s favorite T&M franchise – Keysight VNAs 

I sent a connection invite to Pat Byrne the other day; I didn't realize that he lived just a few miles from us when we were in Portland.

Bill Parzybok, Tom Saponas, Mike Davis, Eric Lessing, John Riggen, and a few others trade notes on occasion--all living in the C Springs area.

From Palo Alto and environs--have you priced the housing here lately?   We should have kept our little Barron and Hilp home down the street from Art Fong by the Palo Alto library.  I looked up the Barrett and Hilp company, just found out that they were instrumental in building the Golden Gate bridge.  They built a few homes in Palo Alto circa 1950, in answer to the cheap and popular Eichlers.  Here's the B&H citation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barrett_and_Hilp.    Jenny and I bought one at 115 Walter Hays Drive for $292,000, a princely sum in our view (and certainly so for my father) in 1986.   It now is listed at nearly $5M.  Sigh.

Anyway, from HP there, how about Steve Joseph, Jerry Brown, Lisa Haeni (who was Tom Steyer's assistant for years after leaving Judee Grenard and me at HP), Will Allen, Neerja Raman, Kumar Karungulam, Bob Frankenberg, Webb McKinney, John Minck, Clark Straw, Al Oliverio, Scott Futryk, and Ron Gonzales.  Howze that for an eclectic group?   All of them are still alive and kickin' -- some more so than others, but hey if we can still get upright and fog a mirror . . .


Monday, May 11, 2026

Views around the loop

 Every "once in a while" something unexpected shows up in my 'in-box' that causes a lump in my throat.  Here is a blogpost by an Irish 'influencer' named Aidan McCullen whom I've mentioned before (mostly since he did some six hours of interviewing me a few months back.   Here's his recent salvo, with a 'sad' HP appended story:  https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:7458857628308463616/

“The Early Bird May Catch the Worm, but the Second Mouse Gets the Cheese” — The Second Mouse (presumably)

This is a comforting story behind the Fast Follower strategy.

There's a fine line between being a strategic second mouse and being a latecomer eating leftovers.

In the 1960s, Chuck House was working on a large-screen display at HP. Dave Packard himself told him to abandon it. Chuck ignored the order. He could see something in the market that HP's own rules had no way of describing, and he kept going. That display became the monitor used for the Apollo moon landing and a $35M business. Chuck later wrote a book about the experience and called it Permission Denied.

Innovation often asks you to break "the syntax" of the company to honour "the context" of the market.

Big organisations fall in love with syntax.
Syntax is the rules, the SOPs, "the way we do things." Syntax scales beautifully, but also stops most companies from spotting the trap before it snaps. The people closest to the context, the Chuck Houses of the world, usually know first. The question is whether the org will let them act on it.

That's the theme of some recent conversations on the show.
Jonathan Brill and Stephen Wunker talked about their new book, AI and the Octopus Organization.

40 years after Chuck House, Jonathan was HP's Global Futurist and Research Director when, in 2009, he sat down with an HP executive to flag a critical touchscreen component coming through one of his clients. The reception was, in his words, "subdued". The strategy was to wait for Apple to launch the iPad, then fast-follow.

So, HP then waited for Microsoft, bought Palm, tried Android. The devices ended up on fire sale. As Jonathan put it in the book, "HP lost because it did everything right." Apple is now worth sixty times HP and HPE combined.

*************      

I don't think I've ever met Jonathan Brill, although a quick perusal of his career shows many common travels.   Here's his impressive Wikipedia page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jonathan_Brill

He must have followed Phil McKinney, another HP futurist long after my time there.  Phil also has had some 'unseemly' comments about HP innovation in recent years, but I won't list them here.

What I will cite is a comparison experience of my own.   I spent 20 years at HP in the oscilloscope division (although I kept trying end-runs like XY displays and Logic Analyzers and Program Development Systems to combat a fierce and capable Tektronix), and then nine years back in Palo Alto and etc. in other roles including Corporate Engineering Director.   Along the way, I gained 'fame' or more accurately 'notoriety' with the David Packard Medal of Defiance, and Electronics' magazine Engineer of the Year, and other accolades (some of them even were appropriate, but most of the work was shared and collegial, not 'mine' alone by any means).   

The key point is that four times I wound up in front of the founders to describe some new 'fool-hardy' projects, and three times I either got permission or was able to continue without being thwarted.  The last time was a bit noteworthy, which I've never put in writing before, and it was more-or-less my swan song for HP.   I was leading a new software division (SESD, which stood for Software Engineering Systems Division), and presenting an idea to HP's Executive Council to change HP's accounting system so that software divisions got credit for part of the computer system sales revenue when their SW wa;s bundled.   

Parenthetic note: I'd already (four years prior), gotten HP to adopt the Return Map for project accounting (see Harvard Biz Review https://hbr.org/1991/01/the-return-map-tracking-product-teams) as noted in today's AI summary: The "Return Map," developed at Hewlett-Packard, provides a way for people from different functions to triangulate on the product development process as a whole. It graphically represents the contributions of all team members to the moment when a project breaks even. The tool serves as a graphical representation designed to align diverse, cross-functional teams toward the same goals.

After giving the talk, I walked out of the room with EVP Lew Platt, soon to be CEO.   He said, "Wow!  I've seen you give many original talks that shocked an audience.  But I've never seen you give one that uniformly pissed off everyone in the room."   

Needless to say, I didn't get the order.  Nor did HP get the message.   So HP Image never competed with Oracle, nor did HP Networks compete with Cisco, and on and on.   Giving the software away to move the hardware worked great for profit-oriented hardware divisions, but was the death-knell for every software division for years.

But that was one failure against three successes.

Later, I spent several years at Intel, and as it happened, I had four opportunities to meet with their Exec Council to pitch some new 'fool-hardy' project.   And four times, they approved it.  But inexplicably, four times they failed to fund it.  For the swan-song after the last pitch (for essentially a "Zoom-like" product in 2005), I left to join Stanford to lead MediaX.  And, a chary view might say, "to learn how academia is able to thwart innovation!"

So, kudos to Jonathan Brill and Phil McKinney and the legions of others who bent their pick on the ever-receding HP innovation gene.